Tuesday, August 24, 2021

An Unexpected Amish Harvest by Carrie Light: Review & Excerpt

An Unexpected Amish Harvest

Book Summary

She’s struggling to forgive…

But it’s the only way to heal her heart.

When Susannah Peachy returns to her grandfather’s potato farm to help out after her grandmother’s injured, she’s not ready to face her ex-beau. But with Peter Lambright pitching in to harvest her grandfather’s crop, she can’t avoid him. For his family’s sake, Peter can’t tell Susannah why he had to leave her. But sharing his secret could make all the difference for their future…

From Love Inspired: Uplifting stories of faith, forgiveness and hope.

About the Author

Carrie Lighte enjoys traveling to Amish communities across the United States and she hopes to visit a few in Canada soon, too. When she isn't writing, reading or researching, she likes to hike, kayak and spend time at the beach.

Connect with the Author

Website: https://www.carrielighte.com/books

Twitter: https://twitter.com/CarrieLighte

My Thoughts

An Unexpected Amish Harvest by Carrie Lighte is the 2nd book in The Amish of New Hope series.  It can be read as a standalone if you have not indulged in Hiding Her Amish Secret.  I thought An Unexpected Amish Harvest was well-written with realistic characters.  Susannah Peachy and Peter Lambright began courting the previous year, but then Peter broke off their courtship without providing a reason.  She wishes to avoid Peter, but it looks like it is not meant to be.  Susannah has loving grandparents who wish to protect her and ensure that she has a safe future.  That future may not be what Susannah has envisioned.  There are a couple of secondary storylines in this tale.  Miscommunication and misunderstandings abound.  There were some good life lessons in this story.  People should not be judged based on their outward appearance and things are not always the way they appear.  We need to remember that there are two sides to every story.  Forgiveness is one of the central themes.  Forgiving someone does more for the person giving it than for the person receiving it.  I like how it all came together into one heartwarming Amish tale.  I appreciated the epilogue that nicely wrapped up the story.  I am eager to read Caring for Her Amish FamilyAn Unexpected Amish Harvest is a sweet story about forgiveness, family, misapprehensions, friends, misperceptions, and love.


When Susannah stayed in New Hope last summer, she had quickly formed a close friendship with Dorcas Troyer. The two young, single women had enjoyed each other’s company again when Susannah returned to New Hope for a week at Christmastime, and they’d written to each other frequently throughout the last year.

In fact, Dorcas was the only person that Susannah had confided in when Peter asked to be her suitor the previous summer…and the only person Susannah had told about their breakup last January. She still remembered teardrops splashing onto the stationery as she wrote,

Peter wouldn’t give me any reason for ending our courtship, other than to say he doesn’t think we’re compatible, after all. But I know it’s because I’ve gained so much weight since last summer.

Her friend had written back,

I’ve known Peter for years and I can’t believe your weight is such an issue for him. Are you sure that’s why he broke up with you? Could it be that he just finds it too difficult to carry on a long-distance courtship?

Susannah highly doubted that. After she’d left New Hope the first time, Peter’s biweekly letters had been filled with proclamations of his affection for her. The couple had called each other at their respective phone shanties at three o’clock every other Sunday. Even after two hours of talking, they’d never run out of things to share and laugh about. And although they had only been able to sneak off for an hour with each other when Susannah came to New Hope last Christmas, they’d agreed their time alone together was the best part of the holiday.

That’s why it was so confusing that four days after she got home, Peter called and said he had decided to end their courtship. The change in his attitude was so abrupt it made Susannah feel as if he was an utter stranger. As if someone else had been pretending to be him on the phone and in his letters. Had been pretending to fall in love with her the way she’d been falling in love with him.

“Why?” she had cried, as bewildered as she was devastated. “I don’t understand.”

“We’re just not a gut match.”

“But why aren’t we a gut match? What has changed all of a sudden?”

“I’m sorry to hurt your feelings like this, Susannah, but I don’t want to discuss it further. Please accept my decision.”

Afterward, she went over it and over it in her mind, trying to figure out what could have possibly changed to make Peter end their relationship. The only thing she could come up with was that once he’d seen her again, he was no longer drawn to her because of how much heavier she’d gotten. Maybe that was why he’d held his tongue about his reason; he hadn’t wanted to hurt her feelings by telling her the truth. But whether he said it aloud or not, she’d been crushed to discover that Peter valued how she looked more than who she was. That he was rejecting her because of her weight gain.

Likewise, in the following months she was disappointed when certain other men accepted her because of her appearance. During the past spring and summer, she’d had no fewer than four bachelors in Dover ask to court her. Susannah would have felt honored, if it hadn’t been for the fact that they’d all known her for at least ten years and they’d never expressed an interest in her until she was slender. 

An Unexpected Amish Harvest is available from Amazon* and Harlequin.  The first novel in The Amish of New Hope series is Hiding Her Amish Secret.  The next book is Caring for Her Amish Family which publishes January 25, 2022.  You can find Carrie Lighte's other novels here.  Thank you for joining me today for the release of An Unexpected Amish Harvest.  I hope you enjoy this charming Amish tale as much as I did.  Tomorrow I am featuring Murder in the Village by Lisa Cutts.  It is the debut of A Belinda Penshurst Mystery series.  I hope you have a friendly day.  Take care, be kind, and Happy Reading!


The Avid Reader 

*This post contains affiliate links.  As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

No comments:

Post a Comment